Ruth Institute Blog

by Andrea Mrozek

Good news. After the recession, things are looking up. Businesses are hiring again. Take for example, Butterfly Body Massage, in Burnaby, British Columbia. They offer “pretty and sexy, open-minded and passionate girls to satisfy your desires,” this as advertised in the Georgia Strait newspaper. They also recently pinned a “Hiring—no experience necessary” sign to their front door.

Now Butterfly Body Massage may do massage. But it’s also clearly doing much more, and is likely a brothel. It is advertising both for new clients and new employees; that would appear to contravene the law, which currently condemns soliciting and living off the avails of prostitution.

Suffice to say, there are problems with the current legal situation. Attempting to claim otherwise would be naïve. But to counter this by fully legalizing prostitution is naïveté on crack.

There are two main reasons why advocates insist legalization is important: safety for the prostitutes, and freedom to do as one pleases. Both are fatuous. Whether legal or illegal, prostitution is not safe and it’s not a choice freely made.

The best evidence comes by way of international example. Amsterdam made prostitution fully legal in 2000, prompting then mayor Job Cohen to say this: “We’ve realized that this is no longer about small-scale entrepreneurs, but that big crime organizations are involved here in trafficking women, drugs, killings and other criminal activities.”

In New Zealand, where prostitution became legal in 2003, a subsequent review published in 2008 reported that few prostitutes interviewed felt legalization did anything about violence on the job. And although prostitution under age 18 remains illegal, no one, says Summer Gill, a policy analyst at the New Zealand-based research group The Maxim Institute, can enforce restrictions on age, as kids don’t carry ID. “The law makes it extremely difficult for these purchasers [of under age sex] to be prosecuted,” says Gill.

Former prostitutes are also available to speak out on the “safety” factor, too. Tania Fiolleau is a former madam who left prostitution and now speaks out against legalization through her web site www.savethewomen.ca. “Prostitution is multi-traumatic whether its physical location is in clubs, brothels, hotels/motels/john’s homes, motor vehicles or on the streets,” writes Fiolleau. “There are women who have said that they felt safer in street prostitution compared to legal Nevada brothels, where they were not permitted to reject any customer. Others commented that on the street they could at least refuse dangerous-appearing or intoxicated customers.”

Then there’s the idea that we should legalize prostitution because people should be free to make their own choices. Yet most prostitutes begin as minors, ages 14 to 16. Furthermore, experts indicate an indelible link between human trafficking, AKA, the modern slave trade, and prostitution.

Keep reading.